Promo vs. Markdown: Your Q4 Discount Strategy

In part one of our holiday series, we made the case for events that give her a reason to come in without leaning on a discount. That's still the goal. But let's be honest: it's Q4. Black Friday is around the corner, your inbox is full of "40% off everything" emails from the big guys, and you've got inventory that needs to turn into cash before January.

Discounting isn't the enemy. Discounting without a plan is. The stores that come out of the holidays in great shape aren't the ones that never take a dollar off. They're the ones that know exactly why they're taking it, on what, and for how long.

So let's start with the two words most of us use interchangeably, and shouldn't.

Promo vs. markdown: they are not the same thing

A promotion is temporary. It's a planned, time-boxed offer with a start date and an end date. The ticket price doesn't change. When the promo ends, the item goes right back to full price. A promo exists to drive traffic and urgency: to get her in the door this weekend instead of someday.

A markdown is permanent. You're lowering the price of a specific item because it isn't selling at the original price, and it's not going back up. The ticket gets re-marked (hello, red pen). A markdown exists to move inventory: to turn a slow seller into cash and free up space and dollars for what's working.

Why does the difference matter? Because they solve different problems, and mixing them up costs you money:

  • Use a promo when the product is fine but you need a reason for her to come in. Your best sellers don't need a markdown. They might benefit from a short, exciting promo on a big shopping day.

  • Use a markdown when the product is the problem. No amount of event energy is going to sell a style she's already passed over for six weeks. Running a 20% storewide promo to fix one slow category just gives away margin on everything that was selling anyway.

  • Track them separately. Most POS systems let you code promotional discounts differently from permanent price changes. Do it. Otherwise you'll never know whether your margin went to Black Friday or to the sweaters you bought too deep.

What each looks like in real life

Promotions

  • "20% off all sweaters, Friday through Sunday only"

  • "$25 off when you spend $150" (great for building the basket)

  • "Buy one candle, get one 50% off" on Small Business Saturday

  • A gift with purchase: spend $100, take home a tote or a mini candle. No price cut at all, and she still feels like she won.

  • Early access for your email list or loyalty customers before the sale opens to everyone

Markdowns

  • A fall jacket that's sold 4 of 24 units since September moves from $128 to $89, permanently

  • Halloween and Thanksgiving décor goes to 50% off the day after the holiday

  • The last two or three sizes of a style get pulled to a clearance rack at 40% off

  • Holiday-specific gift items go to 50% off on December 26, then 75% off in January

Notice the pattern: promos are about when, markdowns are about what.

Take 20–30% now, or 50–75% later

This is the part we most want you to hear. The first markdown is the cheapest markdown.

When something is slow in November, it's tempting to wait. Maybe it'll pick up closer to Christmas. Maybe she'll come back for it. Sometimes she does. More often, you hit January with a rack full of it, and now it's not a 25% decision. It's a 50%, then 75%, then "please just take it" decision.

An early, modest markdown sells the product while there's still demand for it and still time on the calendar. A late markdown is fighting both.

Here's how that plays out on 100 sweaters that cost you $40 each and retail for $100:

Hold at full price, clear in January

Take 25% off in mid-November

Sold at full price ($100)

55 units = $5,500

40 units = $4,000

Sold at 25% off ($75)

—

45 units = $3,375

Sold at 50% off ($50)

25 units = $1,250

15 units = $750

Sold at 75% off ($25)

20 units = $500

—

Total sales

$7,250

$8,125

Gross margin $ (after $4,000 cost)

$3,250

$4,125

Gross margin %

44.8%

50.8%

Same 100 sweaters. The store that "gave away" 25% in November walks away with $875 more in margin, and it had cash in hand weeks earlier to reinvest in the things that were actually selling. Waiting felt like protecting margin. It was the opposite.

The rule of thumb: if it's slow and it's seasonal, act while there's still season left.

The big discount days are coming. Pick your spots.

Here's the 2026 calendar. You don't need to play every one of these. Decide now which ones matter for your customer and what you'll do for each, so you're not making it up at 9 p.m. the night before.

  • Black Friday: Friday, November 27. The big-box day. You will not out-discount Target, and you shouldn't try. If you participate, keep it short (a morning doorbuster, an early-bird hour) or focus on a gift with purchase instead of a deep cut.

  • Small Business Saturday: Saturday, November 28. This is your day. Customers are actively looking to shop local. A modest promo plus a great in-store experience beats a giant discount here. This is a perfect day to pair with an event from part one.

  • Cyber Monday: Monday, November 30. If you sell online, plan a web-only offer so it doesn't cannibalize your in-store weekend.

  • Giving Tuesday: Tuesday, December 1. Skip the discount entirely. Donate a percentage of the day's sales to a local cause. It's a promo that builds goodwill instead of costing margin.

  • Last-minute shopping week: December 18–24, with Saturday the 19th as the peak. She's not price-shopping now, she's panic-shopping. Hold your prices. Push gift wrap, gift cards and curated gift tables instead.

  • After Christmas: December 26 onward. This is markdown season, not promo season. Holiday-specific product goes to clearance and should be gone fast.

One more thing: write your plan down with dates and percentages before Black Friday week. Promos decided in a panic are almost always deeper than they needed to be.

Don't run the same play every time

If you do 25% off everything every Black Friday, she knows. She'll stop buying in early November because she's waiting for it. That's how a promo quietly turns into an expected discount, and how full-price selling erodes.

Keep her guessing (in a good way) by rotating the type of offer:

  • Percent off a category one year, dollar off a threshold the next

  • Gift with purchase instead of a price cut

  • BOGO on an item that's easy to give in pairs (candles, socks, ornaments)

  • Category spotlight: one featured category on promo, everything else at full price

  • VIP early access for your list, then a smaller public offer

  • A mystery offer: scratch-off cards or pull-a-discount envelopes with a range like 10–30%

And change what's included, too. Promoting the same three categories every year trains her to buy those three categories only on sale.

Make the signage do the work

A great offer nobody understands doesn't sell anything. Your signs should answer her questions before she has to ask a busy associate:

  • Say the offer plainly. "20% off all sweaters" beats "Cozy Season Savings!" every time.

  • Say what's included and what isn't. If jewelry is excluded, say so on the sign, not at the register.

  • Say when it ends. "Through Sunday 11/29" creates urgency and protects you from the "but it was on sale last week" conversation.

  • Make it readable from 6–10 feet. Big type, high contrast, few words.

  • Keep promo and clearance visually separate. Promo signs live near the product they cover. Clearance gets its own area and its own look (red tickets, a dedicated rack), so full-price merchandise never looks like it's on sale.

  • Don't bury the full-price product. One sign per fixture is plenty. A store covered in sale signs tells her nothing in there is worth full price.

  • Match it everywhere. The same offer, wording and dates on your windows, your counter, your website, your emails and your Instagram.

And brief your team before doors open. Every associate should be able to explain the offer in one sentence.

Watch the numbers, every week

You can't decide when to mark something down if you don't know how it's selling. These are the key performance indicators worth checking weekly from now through January:

  • Sell-through %. Units sold ÷ units received. This is the single most useful number for markdown decisions. If a seasonal item is far behind where it should be for this point in the season, that's your signal to act.

  • Weeks of supply. Units on hand ÷ average units sold per week. If you have 12 weeks of supply and 5 weeks of season left, you already know the answer.

  • Gross margin dollars, not just sales. A promo that lifts sales 15% but drops margin 25% was not a win.

  • Markdown and promo dollars as a % of sales, tracked separately so you know where the margin went.

  • Average transaction and units per transaction. Threshold offers ("$25 off $150") should push these up. If they don't, the offer isn't working.

  • Traffic and conversion. Did the promo bring more people in, or just give a discount to people who were coming anyway?

  • Year-over-year comparison for the same promo window, so you can tell whether this year's offer did better or worse than last year's.

After each big promo, write down three things: what you ran, what it did, and what you'd change. Next year's plan starts there.

Decide when you want to be out of it

Every seasonal category should have an exit date, and you should pick it before the season, not when you're staring at a full rack in January. Some examples:

  • Holiday décor and Christmas-specific gifts: out by Christmas Eve, or within the first week after. Nobody's buying a Santa mug in February.

  • Winter accessories (hats, gloves, scarves): sell through by mid-to-late January, before it's lost its urgency.

  • Heavy outerwear and cold-weather apparel: out by February, so the floor and your open-to-buy are clear for spring.

Then work backwards. Say you have 60 units of a holiday item, 6 weeks until your exit date, and you're selling 5 a week. At that pace you'll still have 30 left at the finish line. You need to sell 10 a week. That's not a problem to solve on December 26. That's a problem to solve this week, with a modest markdown or a spot in your next promo.

Being out of it on time isn't just about the leftover units. It frees up cash and floor space for the product that comes next, and it means your January isn't spent marking things down to 75% off.

The bottom line

Promos are temporary and drive traffic. Markdowns are permanent and move product. Use each for its own job, plan them before the rush, change up your offers so she doesn't learn to wait, sign them clearly, and watch your numbers every week.

Most of all: when something is slow, don't wait for it to become a clearance problem. A 20–30% decision today is far cheaper than the 50–75% decision you'll be making in January.

Need help building your Q4 promo calendar or reviewing your markdown plan? That's exactly what we do. And if you missed it, catch part one of our holiday series on events that sell at full price.

KC Wolfe